Black liquid eyeliner pretty much features in my everyday makeup, and after using L’Oreal Superliner Perfect Slim felt tip eyeliner for around a year (you can check out my review here) I fancied a bit of a change! So on a trip to Boots I decided to pick up the Soap & Glory Supercat Liquid Black Eyeliner Pen after reading lots of great reviews about it.
Just like the L’Oreal Perfect Slim, Soap & Glory Supercat is a felt tip liner, which allows you to achieve the same effect as a normal liquid eyeliner, but makes the process of achieving this around 10 time easier! After years of using (and still struggling!) to use normal liquid eyeliner, felt tip liners were a very welcomed addition to my makeup bag!
Soap & Glory Supercat retails for £6 (that’s 99p less than the L’Oreal Perfect Slim) – but the question is, how does it compare!?
The felt tip nib of the Soap & Glory Supercat liner is slightly shorter and a bit sturdier than the L’Oreal Perfect Slim. I must admit, after first switching over to the Soap & Glory liner I found it slightly more tricky to use than the L’Oreal Perfect Slim, however after using it for around a week or so the nib softened slightly making it much easier to draw on a precise line – even more so than the L’Oreal Perfect Slim due to its slightly shorter nib allowing more control. As you can see in the photos, Supercat helps achieve a very black line and I noticed that since first using Soap & Glory Supercat, the liner seems to have got black-er!
Soap & Glory Supercat has also quite impressive staying power and will easily last all day – it just does not budge! (Unless tears are involved – then it most definitely will, as will most other non-waterproof eyeliners!)
Overall, I would highly recommend this product – I would still happily use L’Oreal Superliner Perfect Slim, however for 99p less and pretty much the same quality (if not ever so slightly better!) Soap & Glory Supercat is definitely the winner!
What do you think of felt tip liners? Which one should I try out next?
Soap & Glory Supercat is available from Boots.com